Review: Flash: The Fastest Man Alive: Lightning in a Bottle trade paperback (DC Comics)

4 comments | Tags:

Thursday, August 09, 2007

Flash: The Fastest Man Alive - Lightning in a Bottle is, to be blunt, a failure of writing and art. What's worse, however, is that the two don't fail at the same time--there are moments where Danny Bilson and Paul Demeo's story shows some promise, just as the art offers a bright spot--Karl Kerschl--against Ken Lashley's just-wrong-for-this series illustrations. The result is a story that probably had some potential in its inception, but fails to distinguish itself in the production.

One Year Later, Bart Allen works at Keystone Motors, and Jay Garrick is the Flash. An accident reveals that Bart still carries the Speed Force inside of him, but he's hesitant to use it. A series of sabotage attacks forces Bart to wear Barry Allen's old Flash uniform, the only thing that can contain the Speed Force, in order to protect his friends, including STAR Labs scientist Dr. Valerie Perez. Bart ultimately must become the Flash in order to stop the vigilante violence of his friend Griff, facing his fear in the process.

This new Flash series had a considerably high reputation to live up to. Mark Waid defined the Flash for an era, creating the Speed Force that's become a mainstay of DC Comics lore. Bilson and Demeo set out with good intentions, revising Bart Allen's origin such that he receives his powers accidentally, much the same way as the Flashes before him. This accident, however, never really takes place (Bart reveals his powers when Griff is caught in an accident).

Similarly, Bart's internalizing of the Speed Force is rife with potential--especially when Bart can benefit from the wisdom of Flashes past--but why Bart's so hesitant to use the Speed Force is never fully explained. Supposedly the Speed Force is eating Bart alive, but we never see any evidence of this, and it's not clear why Bart's so afraid of the super-bursts of speed that he receives. As with Firestorm, the lacking comics pseudo-science here is just boring, especially after Mark Waid's efforts.

I did appreciate Bilson and Demeo's attempt to keep Bart in Keystone's motor city, even going so far as to use the detectives Chyre and Morillo that Geoff Johns created. But whereas Johns' Flash run felt fully rooted in union politics, Bilson and Demeo's intial bad guy is a stereotypical disgruntled employee. Griffen, Bart's friend-turned-enemy, needs very much to be sympathetic--but as was the problem with Nightwing: Brothers in Blood, the character is so full of slang and juvenile humor that he comes off as a caricature. Valerie Perez, the daughter of a former Flash villain, is a bright spot, offering ties to Bart's Kid Flash days; here, however, as well as in other instances, it seems the writers don't quite understand Bart's Impulse to Kid Flash timeline, and these shoddy details harm the book overall.

In comparison to Waid and Johns' Flash runs, Fastest Man Alive just doesn't reflect the same fervor. Ken Lashley has plenty of comic book experience, but his art seems flat compared to past Flash artists Scott Kolins, Mike Wieringo, Howard Porter or even this trade's fill-in artist Karl Kerschl, whose more cartoony style offers a much better fit. I was wary of Kerschl when he first did guest-spots in Superman, but the early boxiness of his work has given way to a smoothness that works great in titles like Teen Titans.

It's hard to review Lightning in a Bottle without casting an eye toward what we know is to come in the next trade. It's actually possible to believe the thirteen issues of this Flash series were planned, given some of the doom and gloom prophecies found in this trade--though even those feel largely un-Flash-like coming from the upbeat Wally West and Barry Allen. Fastest Man Alive just never offers the zip of its predecessors, though again the concept seems sound--it's just too bad Bart Allen had to pay for other people's difficulties.

[Contains full covers.]

We're finding ourselves in a "new character" subsection of One Year Later. Coming up next ... the All-New Atom! Come join!
Collected Editions 2014 Comic Book Gift Guide
Get the Collected Editions scoop before anyone else -- on Facebook!

4 comments:

  1. I think that you will like the next Flash: The Fastest Man Alive trade... even though you know the ending.
    If you are able to read it and pretend you don't know the ending, its 5 billion times better than this trade.

    I do look forward to your review of the new Atom, it took a while to grow on me but it is a very entertaining book: check the 2nd image in this post - http://www.spacebooger.com/index.php/2007/08/06/last-week-in-comics-crossover-is-a-holiday-in-dcs-heaven/

    ReplyDelete
  2. Considering 'Ringo's passing and the trouble I was having with DC anyway...I can safely say I'm probably never gonna read this. It feels too much like a slap. No offense intended. Just doesn't feel right. Both Marvel and DC owe that man a great tribute because frankly, he saved their bacon on a couple of their franchises in my opnion.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Fred -- City on the Edge of his dog's ass, indeed! I'll let you know what I think of the second trade.

    Michael -- Mike Wieringo's passing is very sad. His art was great and by all accounts he was a nice guy. He'll be missed.

    ReplyDelete
  4. You're much kinder about this trade than I would have been. There was sloppiness in writing, art and definitely editorial. Bilson & DeMeo turned in something that they thought worked. Lashley was perhaps the biggest surprise. His art was horribly off. Editorial obviously did not give them any feedback or critiques. This was the first time in a long time I was dreading each issue of the Flash.
    Unfortunately, to this day, Flash has not recovered the quality it had before their run.

    ReplyDelete