Updates via Twitter

    Monday, November 26, 2007

    Review: Transformers: Stormbringer trade paperback (IDW)

    3 comments | Tag:

    [This review comes from Doug Glassman:]

    IDW’s current Transformers series is broken up into a series of six-issue mini-series, making for easy collection into trades. Between “Infiltration” and “Escalation” came a four-issue arc called “Stormbringer” that took the story away from Earth and back to the Transformers’ home planet of Cybertron. Many fans were eagerly awaiting the story because of the promise of “No humans.” “Relatable human characters” are often inserted into Transformers stories. At times, they work, such as Sam Witwicky in the recent live action film. And sometimes, they don’t work, like the annoying kids in the Unicron Trilogy of shows (Armada, Energon and Cybertron). Humans were also prevalent in “Infiltration”, and some fans thought that they were incredibly intrusive. Can Transformers work without relatable human characters?

    Absolutely.

    I’ll admit up front that part of the reason Stormbringer appealed to me was one of its starring characters: Jetfire. This character made it to the original show only in the altered form of Skyfire because he was based on the Valkyrie toy from Macross/Robotech. Something about his inhuman face, his neat alternate mode and his pursuit of science appealed to me, and they all transferred across to his new form in Stormbringer. Though he’s a bit clueless here, the Jetfire action did not disappoint this Jetfire fanboy.

    For those that are completely new to the Transformers franchise, Stormbringer might not be the best book to start with. Its countless cameos and somewhat convoluted plot rely on some old franchise stand-bys such as Pretenders and the Wreckers. Because Simon Furman, the long-time Transformers comics author, wrote this arc, Bludgeon and Thunderwing are featured characters. (I’m personally amazed that Grimlock didn’t worm his way in, though he does make an appearance in Beast Wars: The Gathering). All of the IDW Transformers stories connect to each other to form a weaving story that emulates the original Generation One but introduces a number of new concepts. Surprisingly, you don’t have to read the preceding arc, “Infiltration,” to understand what is going on. I read Stormbringer first and understood it perfectly. The only real interaction with the previous arc is the explanation of where Optimus Prime is arriving from at the end of “Infiltration."

    Speaking of which, Optimus is the main character of Stormbringer despite its early focus on Jetfire. This is a compromise of sorts: Prime is here while Megatron is on Earth during “Infiltration.” The two interact in Stormbringer only through flashbacks. One might be surprised by the amount of armament Optimus packs in this arc. Other famous Transformers appear throughout, such as Springer, the Technobots, Thrust and the Predacons, along with Thunderwing himself for the Marvel UK faithful, though he has little to say.

    All of these characters are illustrated by Don Figueroa, who in my opinion is the best artist IDW has on hand. My nickname for him is the “George Perez of Transformers.” He can draw massive crowd scenes and make every character stand out. More importantly, he has a gift for designing transformation schemes and Cybertronian alternate modes. (For the Transformers newbie, they are “Cybertronian” in the sense that they are the alternate modes that the Transformers had before they reached Earth). This is actually the second time he has done a great number of Cybertronian modes; he had to redesign some of his War Within creations to avoid trademark issues. His designs are “toyetic”—they can easily be turned into action figures, and some of them already have. In fact, his design for Jetfire made its way to retailer shelves as the Jetfire toy in the Classics line, and all of the figures in the sadly cancelled Titanium line were designed by Don.

    Sometimes it takes clean artwork to see some of the design genius. Stormbringer, like a majority of the IDW trades, has a sketch section in the back showing off Figueroa’s handiwork. There are also the covers, which feature the majority of G1 characters, many of whom never show up in the book. He even explains the hard-to-see final transformation of Thunderwing. Yes, all this great design work comes at a price: Figueroa sometimes has difficulty conveying the action. But that’s mostly because of the awkward panel layout later on in the book. You can work it out after a few reads.

    Is Stormbringer for the brand-new fan coming off of the film? No. It’s a fun “fight the monster” story made entertaining by the high number of obscure Transformers cameos. A newbie would be better off starting with the “Spotlight” issues, which take closer looks at individual facets of the IDW continuity. Or you could start with the weaker “Infiltration,” which, while a decent introduction, suffers a bit from the humans involved. Still, Stormbringer is at least worth flipping through for the design work alone.

    [Contains sketch pages, cover gallery, sketch pages. $17.99.]

    3 comments
    JLE said...

    Off-topic: Have you read my answer about the Lobo: Portrait of a bastich tpb? Are you going to pick it? I forgot to say you that if you like Preacher you will enjoy this one.
    I asked you a few weeks ago about The Question: Zen and Violence tpb. I have read the six issues included in it, and they are amazing. I will buy it definitely.
    Sorry for the off-topic.
    Regards.

    collectededitions said...

    JLE -- I was a fan of the Lobo series for a bit, but never read any of the specials or minis; I'm betting Portrait of a Bastich has some quintissential Lobo stuff in it, but I just don't know -- being not necessarily tied to current events and all -- if my budget could support it. I'll put it on my wishlist, let's say; the Question trade is there, too.

    And so as not to take away from Doug's Transformers review, check back on Thursday, folks, when Doug reviews Transformers: Beast Wars: The Gathering!

    JLE said...

    >>I was a fan of the Lobo series for a bit, but never read any of the specials or minis.
    These miniseries are much better than regular series, so if you liked those ones, you'll love Portrait of a bastich for sure.

    Post a Comment

    Subscribe to feed
    Subscribe to comments
    Subscribe to feeds via e-mail:

    Subscribe to RSS Feed Recent Entries

    Popular Posts

    Labels

    Subscribe to RSS Feed Recent Comments

    Advertise on this site Support system

    Archived Reviews

    52, Vol. 1
    52, Vol. 2
    52, Vol. 3
    52, Vol. 4
    52: The Companion
    52: World War III
    Absolute Authority
    Absolute Batman: Hush
    Absolute DC The New Frontier
    Absolute Green Lantern: Rebirth
    Absolute Watchmen
    Adam Strange: Planet Heist
    Alice in Sunderland
    All New Atom: Future/Past
    All New Atom: My Life in Miniature
    All New Atom: Small Wonder
    All New Atom: The Hunt for Ray Palmer
    Amazing Spider-Man Omnibus
    American Splendor
    Animal Man
    Animal Man: Deux Ex Machina
    Animal Man: Origin of the Species
    Aquaman, Sword of Atlantis: Once and Future
    Avengers Forever
    Batgirl: Destruction's Daughter
    Batgirl: Year One
    Batman and the Outsiders: The Chrysalis
    Batman and the Outsiders: The Snare
    Batman: Batman and Son
    Batman: Death and the City
    Batman: Detective
    Batman: Face the Face
    Batman: Gotham Underground
    Batman: Hush Returns
    Batman: R.I.P. The Deluxe Edition
    Batman: The Black Glove
    Batman: The Man Who Laughs
    Batman: The Resurrection of Ra's Al Ghul
    Batman: Turning Points
    Batman: Under the Hood, Vol. 1
    Batman: Under the Hood, Vol. 2
    Batman: War Crimes
    Batman: War Drums
    Batman: War Games Act One
    Batman: War Games Act Three
    Batman: War Games Act Two
    Batman: Whatever Happened to the Caped Crusader? The Deluxe Edition
    Birds of Prey: Between Dark & Dawn
    Birds of Prey: Blood and Circuits
    Birds of Prey: Club Kids
    Birds of Prey: Dead of Winter
    Birds of Prey: Metropolis or Dust
    Birds of Prey: Perfect Pitch
    Birds of Prey: Platinum Flats
    Birds of Prey: Sensei & Student
    Birds of Prey: The Battle Within
    Bizarre New World: Population Explosion
    Blue Beetle: End Game
    Blue Beetle: Reach for the Stars
    Blue Beetle: Road Trip
    Blue Beetle: Shellshocked
    Booster Gold: 52 Pick-Up
    Booster Gold: Blue and Gold
    Booster Gold: Reality Lost
    Brave and the Bold: The Lords of Luck
    Captain America and the Falcoln: Secret Empire
    Captain America: The Death of Captain America
    Captain Atom: Armageddon
    Catwoman: Catwoman Dies
    Catwoman: Crime Pays
    Catwoman: It's Only a Movie
    Catwoman: Relentless
    Catwoman: The Dark End of the Street
    Catwoman: The Long Road Home
    Catwoman: The Replacements
    Catwoman: Wild Ride
    Checkmate: A King's Game
    Checkmate: Chimera
    Checkmate: Fall of the Wall
    Checkmate: Pawn Breaks
    Countdown to Adventure
    Countdown to Final Crisis, Vol. 1
    Countdown to Final Crisis, Vol. 2
    Countdown to Final Crisis, Vol. 3
    Countdown to Final Crisis, Vol. 4
    Countdown to Final Crisis: Arena
    Countdown to Infinite Crisis
    Crisis on Infinite Earths: The Absolute Edition
    Daredevil: The Devil, Inside and Out, Vol. 1
    Daredevil: The Devil, Inside and Out, Vol. 2
    Day of Vengeance
    Death of the New Gods
    Dr. Strange: The Oath
    Essential Nova
    Essential Spider-Man
    Ex Machina: The First Hundred Days
    Fables: Arabian Nights (And Days)
    Fables: Homelands
    Fables: The Mean Seasons
    Fallen Angel, Vol. 1
    Fallen Angel: Down to Earth
    Final Crisis
    Final Crisis Companion
    Final Crisis: Revelations
    Final Crisis: Rogues' Revenge
    Firestorm: The Nuclear Man: Reborn
    Flash, The Fastest Man Alive: Full Throttle
    Flash, The Fastest Man Alive: Lightning in a Bottle
    Flash: Blood Will Run
    Flash: Ignition
    Flash: Rogue War
    Flash: The Secret of Barry Allen
    Flash: Wonderland
    Formerly Known as the Justice League
    Gotham Central: Dead Robin
    Gotham Central: Half a Life
    Gotham Central: In the Line of Duty
    Gotham Central: The Quick and the Dead
    Gotham Central: Unresolved Targets
    Green Arrow: City Walls
    Green Arrow: Crawling Through the Wreckage
    Green Arrow: Heading into the Light
    Green Arrow: Moving Targets
    Green Arrow: Road to Jericho
    Green Arrow: Year One
    Green Arrow/Black Canary: A League of Their Own
    Green Arrow/Black Canary: Family Business
    Green Arrow/Black Canary: For Better or For Worse
    Green Arrow/Black Canary: Road to the Altar
    Green Arrow/Black Canary: The Wedding Album
    Green Lantern Corps: Recharge
    Green Lantern Corps: Ring Quest
    Green Lantern Corps: Sins of the Star Sapphire
    Green Lantern Corps: The Dark Side of Green
    Green Lantern Corps: To Be a Lantern
    Green Lantern Legacy: The Last Will of Hal Jordan
    Green Lantern: No Fear
    Green Lantern: Rage of the Red Lanterns
    Green Lantern: Rebirth
    Green Lantern: Revenge of the Green Lanterns
    Green Lantern: Secret Origin
    Green Lantern: Tales of the Sinestro Corps
    Green Lantern: The Sinestro Corps War Book One
    Green Lantern: The Sinestro Corps War Book Two
    Green Lantern: Wanted – Hal Jordan
    Hawkgirl: Hawkman Returns
    Hawkgirl: The Maw
    Hawkman: Rise of the Golden Eagle
    Hawkman: Wings of Fury
    Helmet of Fate
    Huntress: Darknight Daughter
    Identity Crisis
    Incredible Change-Bots
    Infinite Crisis
    Infinite Crisis #1
    Infinite Crisis #2
    Infinite Crisis #3
    Infinite Crisis #4
    Infinite Crisis #5
    Infinite Crisis #6
    Infinite Crisis #7
    Infinite Crisis Aftermath: The Battle for Bludhaven
    Infinite Crisis Aftermath: The Spectre
    Infinite Crisis Companion
    Infinite Crisis novelization
    Infinity Inc.: Luthor's Monsters
    Infinity Inc.: The Bogeyman
    Invincible Iron Man: Five Nightmares
    Ion: The Dying Flame
    Ion: The Torchbearer
    Jack Kirby's Fourth World Omnibus, Vol. 1
    Jack Kirby's Fourth World Omnibus, Vol. 2
    Jack Kirby's Fourth World Omnibus, Vol. 3
    Jack Kirby's Fourth World Omnibus, Vol. 4
    Jack Kirby's Omac: One Man Army Corps
    JLA Classified: I Can't Believe It's Not the Justice League
    JLA Classified: Ultramarine Corps
    JLA: Crisis of Conscience
    JLA: Pain of the Gods
    JLA: Syndicate Rules
    JLA: The Tenth Circle
    JLA: Trial by Fire
    JLA: World Without a Justice League
    JSA All-Stars
    JSA Classified: Honor Among Thieves
    JSA Presents: Stars and S.T.R.I.P.E., Vol. 1
    JSA: Black Reign
    JSA: Black Vengeance
    JSA: Ghost Stories
    JSA: Lost
    JSA: Mixed Signals
    JSA: Princes of Darkness
    JSA: The Liberty Files
    Justice League Elite, Vol. 1
    Justice League Elite, Vol. 2
    Justice League of America Hereby Elects . . .
    Justice League of America: Sanctuary
    Justice League of America: The Injustice League
    Justice League of America: The Lightning Saga
    Justice League of America: The Tornado's Path
    Justice Society of America: The Next Age
    Justice Society of America: Thy Kingdom Come Book One
    Justice Society of America: Thy Kingdom Come Book Three
    Justice Society of America: Thy Kingdom Come Book Two
    Kingdom Come
    Legion of Super-Heroes: Death of a Dream
    Legion of Super-Heroes: Enemy Manifest
    Legion of Super-Heroes: Enemy Rising
    Legion of Super-Heroes: Teenage Revolution
    Lex Luthor: Man of Steel
    Majestic: Strange New Visitor
    Manhunter: Origins
    Manhunter: Street Justice
    Manhunter: Trial by Fire
    Manhunter: Unleashed
    Martian Manhunter: The Others Among Us
    Marvel Boy
    Marvel Masterworks: Amazing Spider-Man
    Mystery in Space, Vol. 1
    Nightwing: Brothers in Blood
    Nightwing: Freefall
    Nightwing: Love and War
    Nightwing: Mobbed Up
    Nightwing: On the Razor's Edge
    Nightwing: Renegade
    Nightwing: The Great Leap
    Nightwing: The Lost Year
    Nightwing: Year One
    Ocean
    Omac Project
    Outsiders: Crisis Intervention
    Outsiders: Five of a Kind
    Outsiders: Pay as You Go
    Outsiders: The Good Fight
    Outsiders: Wanted
    Outsiders/Checkmate: Checkout
    Pedro and Me
    Perhapanauts: First Blood
    Power Girl
    Question: The Five Books of Blood
    Rann-Thanagar War
    Robin: Days of Fire and Madness
    Robin: Search for a Hero
    Robin: Teenage Wasteland
    Robin: The Big Leagues
    Robin: To Kill a Bird
    Robin: Violent Tendencies
    Robin: Wanted
    Robin: Year One
    Robin/Batgirl: Fresh Blood
    Saga of the Swamp Thing
    Salvation Run
    Scurvy Dogs: Rags to Riches
    Secret Six: Six Degrees of Devastation
    Secret Six: Unhinged
    Seven Soldiers of Victory, Vol. 1
    Seven Soldiers of Victory, Vol. 2
    Seven Soldiers of Victory, Vol. 3
    Seven Soldiers of Victory, Vol. 4
    Shadowpact: Cursed
    Shadowpact: Darkness and Light
    Shadowpact: The Burning Age
    Shadowpact: The Pentacle Plot
    Showcase Presents: House of Secrets
    Space Ghost
    Spectre: Tales of the Unexpected
    Star Wars: Legacy: Broken
    Suicide Squad: From the Ashes
    Supergirl and the Legion of Super-Heroes: Adult Education
    Supergirl and the Legion of Super-Heroes: Dominator War
    Supergirl and the Legion of Super-Heroes: Strange Visitor from Another Century
    Supergirl and the Legion of Super-Heroes: The Quest for Cosmic Boy
    Supergirl: Beyond Good and Evil
    Supergirl: Candor
    Supergirl: Identity
    Supergirl: Power
    Supergirl: Way of the World
    Superman and the Legion of Super-Heroes
    Superman vs. The Flash
    Superman: 3-2-1 Action
    Superman: Back in Action
    Superman: Brainiac
    Superman: Camelot Falls, Vol. 1
    Superman: Camelot Falls, Vol. 2
    Superman: Escape from Bizarro World
    Superman: In the Name of Gog
    Superman: Infinite Crisis
    Superman: Last Son
    Superman: New Krypton, Vol. 1
    Superman: New Krypton, Vol. 2
    Superman: Redemption
    Superman: Ruin Revealed
    Superman: Sacrifice
    Superman: Shadows Linger
    Superman: Strange Attractors
    Superman: That Healing Touch
    Superman: The Coming of Atlas
    Superman: The Journey
    Superman: The Third Kryptonian
    Superman: The Wrath of Gog
    Superman: Up, Up and Away
    Superman/Batman: Absolute Power
    Superman/Batman: Enemies Among Us
    Superman/Batman: Finest Worlds
    Superman/Batman: Supergirl
    Superman/Batman: The Search for Kryptonite
    Superman/Batman: Torment
    Superman/Batman: Vengeance
    Superman/Shazam: First Thunder
    Supermarket
    Tales from the Bully Pulpit
    Tangent Comics, Vol. 1
    Tangent Comics, Vol. 2
    Tangent Comics, Vol. 3
    Tangent: Superman's Reign
    Teen Titans: Beast Boys & Girls
    Teen Titans: Changing of the Guard
    Teen Titans: Life and Death
    Teen Titans: On the Clock
    Teen Titans: The Future is Now
    Teen Titans: Titans Around the World
    Teen Titans: Titans East
    Teen Titans: Titans of Tomorrow
    Teen Titans/Outsiders: The Death and Return of Donna Troy
    Teen Titans/Outsiders: The Insiders
    Terror Titans
    The Death of Captain America: The Burden of Dreams
    The Death of Captain America: The Man Who Bought America
    Thunderbolts: Justice, Like Lightning
    Top 10
    Transformers: Beast Wars: The Gathering
    Transformers: Stormbringer
    Trials of Shazam, Vol. 1
    Trials of Shazam, Vol. 2
    Uncanny X-Men: Divided We Fall
    Uncle Sam and the Freedom Fighters
    Uncle Sam and the Freedom Fighters: Brave New World
    Villains United
    Walking Dead: Days Gone By
    Wolverine: Get Mystique
    Wonder Woman: Amazons Attack
    Wonder Woman: Bitter Rivals
    Wonder Woman: Down to Earth
    Wonder Woman: Eyes of the Gorgon
    Wonder Woman: Land of the Dead
    Wonder Woman: Mission's End
    Wonder Woman: The Ends of the Earth
    Wonder Woman: Who is Wonder Woman?
    Y: The Last Man: Girl on Girl
    Y: The Last Man: Paper Dolls
    Y: The Last Man: Ring of Truth
    Year One: Batman/Ra's Al Ghul
    52 Absolute edition Action Comics Adventures of Superman Alan Moore America's Best Animal Man Aquaman Atom Authority Avengers Batgirl Batman Birds of Prey Black Canary Blue Beetle Bob Hodges Booster Gold Brad Meltzer Brave and the Bold Brian Vaughan CafePress Captain America Captain Atom Captain Marvel cartoons Catwoman Checkmate Civil War commentary Countdown Daredevil Darwyn Cooke Dave Gibbons DC Direct DC TPB Timeline DC Universe puzzle DC: New Frontier Devin Grayson Doug Glassman Ed Brubaker Ex Machina Fables Fallen Angel Final Crisis Flash Frank Miller Gail Simone Geoff Johns gift guide Gotham Central Green Arrow Green Lantern Greg Cox Greg Rucka hardcovers Harvey Pekar Hawkman Heroes Identity Crisis Infinite Crisis Infinity Inc. iron man Jack Kirby James Robinson JSA jsa classified Judd Winick Justice League Elite Justice League of America Justice Society of America Keith Giffen Kurt Busiek Legion of Super-Heroes majestic Manhunter Marvel Boy Marvel Comics Marvel Essentials Marvel Masterworks mini-review Mystery in Space news Newsarama Nightwing Nova Odds and Ends OMAC Project One Year Later Outsiders Perhapanauts Power Girl Question Red Hood retrospective review Richard Donner Robin Sandman Secret Six Seven Soldiers of Victory Shadowpact Showcase Presents solicitations Spectre spider-man Star Wars Supergirl Superman superman/Batman supermarket Swamp Thing Tangent Teen Titans Thunderbolts Top Ten Trade Perspectives Uncle Sam and the Freedom Fighters Vertigo Walking Dead Watchmen Wildstorm Wizard Wonder Woman X-Men Y: The Last Man

    Blog DC TPB TIMELINE UPDATES

    Valued Readers

    Comic  Blog Elite

    Blog Directory - Blogged

    Powered By Blogger

    Web Analytics